برخی از نمرات Silent Hill: Book of Memories منتشر شد:
(لیست نمرات به روز خواهد شد)

Digital Chumps: 8.2
Hardcore Gamer Magazine: 8
Cheat Code Central: 7.4
PSX-Sense.nl: 7
Destructoid: 6.5
MMGN.com: 6.5
ZTGameDomain: 6.5
Vandal Online: 6.3
3DJuegos: 6.2
Gamereactor Denmark: 6
XGN: 6
GameSpot: 6
IGN: 6
Joystiq: 6
Playstation Official Magazine UK: 5
Pocket Gamer UK: 4
GamesRadar: 4
Canadian Online Gamers: 3.5
Metro GameCentral: 3

میانگین :

Metascore: 56
Gamerankings: 62%